An Edited Executive Summary
D.A.R.E. Study Shows Positive Impact on Students and Families
By David L. Rechenmacher, M.S., Public Affairs Manager, Downers Grove Police Department,
Illinois
The D.A.R.E. Program Expanding in Illinois
The Drug Abuse Resistance Education (D.A.R.E.) Program which was first piloted in six
Downers Grove, Illinois elementary schools in January 1993, has expanded to all ten
District schools and four private schools in just two and one-half years. Expansion is
anticipated into the Downers Grove Middle School system.
Original Goals
The original goals of the program were to provide students with skills to recognize and
resist the social pressures to experiment with alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs; teach
positive alternatives to destructive behaviors; and build a positive relationship between
the Police Department and the community.
Although the feedback received relative to the program indicated these original goals
were being met or exceeded, officials and the Police Department desired a more definitive
indicator of the program's degree of success.
A Survey developed
A comprehensive survey instrument design was developed to measure the perceptions of
students, parents, and educators relative to program visibility. 1,500 surveys, consisting
of 18 questions each, were distributed to D.A.R.E. graduates, parents and school
administrators. Over 57% of the surveys were completed and returned, which is considered a
high return rate.
Four general areas were surveyed: effect on student's life skills and behavior;
communication within the family; attitudes and relations with the police; and overall
effectiveness of the program.
Survey Responses
The entire survey yielded positive responses relating to the program. One question
measured resistance skills. Ninety-eight percent of the students surveyed believed the
program had a significant level of effectiveness in teaching skills.
Students also responded strongly to a question that examined the concept of
consequences. Ninety-eight point two percent of students surveyed believed the program
had a measure of effectiveness in teaching the concept of consequences.
The survey also indicated that the D.A.R.E. Program developed skills for mitigating the
effects of peer pressure related to negative behavior. When asked if they would know
how to respond to a friend if asked to do something that they didn't want to do, 88.3% of
the student respondents stated they would know how to respond.
When surveyed on whether the D.A.R.E. officers contributed to the development of
positive student attitudes toward the D.A.R.E. officers and all police in general. 86.3%
of the parents and 100% of educators surveyed believe the program is beneficial in shaping
positive attitudes towards all police.
The overall effectiveness of the Downers Grove D.A.R.E. Program is perceived by the
students, parents and educators combined was either "very good" or good in 92%
of those surveyed.
The measure of Effectiveness
In recent years there have been a number of critical studies that have attempted to
measure the cost effectiveness and long term impact on D.A.R.E. graduates relating to
substance abuse, life skills and attitudes. Studies of this type are difficult to conduct
due to the high mobility of our society, which makes long-term tracking and follow-up
interviews difficult or impossible. Some of these studies have been critical and negative
relative to the long term benefits of D.A.R.E., but the methodology and ability to track
participants over a protracted period raises questions as to the validity of some of these
study results.
The measure of effectiveness for the D.A.R.E. program cannot be looked upon as an exact
science, but rather one of indicators.
When you examine the objective of D.A.R.E. for Downers Grove, such as teaching life
skills, shaping positive attitudes, and opening lines of communication, our survey
results, along with every other indicator, affirm that the Downers Grove D.A.R.E.
Program has been, and continues to be, very successful.
|